The role of indirect coffee trading in the supply chain

Although commonly found in the coffee industry, the concept of indirect coffee trading has not been formally defined or consistently applied across the industry. In general terms, indirect coffee trading refers to transactions in which coffee is sold by producers (farmers or cooperatives) to consumers through one or more intermediaries, such as exporters, brokers, importers, or large distributors, roasters, and retailers.

In the indirect trading model, intermediaries play a crucial role in logistics, quality control, and connecting farmers in remote areas with larger markets. These intermediaries often have agents in various countries to ensure a stable supply of coffee to local markets.

Due to their primary role in ensuring basic supply and demand, these intermediaries typically have limited knowledge of specific product details such as production cycles, farm stories, and sustainability factors. Additionally, with multiple layers of intermediaries involved in the transaction, each party takes a share of the “coffee pie,” leaving coffee farmers with less control over the price they receive.

Overall, the indirect trading model often lacks transparency, and it is difficult to trace the supply chain with clarity.

With many components in the coffee supply chain and the complexity of business operations, the indirect coffee trading model has several key features:

Complex distribution Process:
In indirect coffee trading, products pass through several stages involving multiple intermediaries. Each intermediary plays a specific role and influences how the product is transported and distributed.

For example, a coffee producer in Colombia might sell their product to an international exporter. The exporter then transfers the coffee to an importer in the U.S., who distributes it to local distributors, and finally, the distributor supplies it to retail outlets like Starbucks.

• Diverse Participants: These include producers, agents, brokers, export-import cooperatives, etc. Each plays a different role in the distribution process. For example, agents may be responsible for finding customers and conducting transactions, while export-import cooperatives may focus on consolidating products from many small producers to meet export volume requirements.
• Multiple Intermediaries: Products must pass through several steps before reaching consumers, with each stage carrying risks related to quality and timing. For instance, agricultural products may travel from farms to storage facilities, distribution centers, exporters, importers, wholesalers, and finally, retail stores before reaching consumers.
• Diverse Distribution Channels: Products can be distributed through various channels such as wholesale, retail, online, or specialty stores. Each channel has its own characteristics and serves different customer segments. For example, traditional retail may cater to customers who prefer in-person shopping, while online channels serve those who value convenience and remote purchasing.

Shared Responsibilities and Risk Management:
Intermediaries in the indirect coffee supply chain bear different responsibilities, from logistics to quality control.

• Distributed Responsibility: Each intermediary is responsible for only a portion of the process, making it challenging to clearly identify accountability when problems arise. For instance, if a product is damaged, it can be difficult to determine whether the fault lies with the producer, the transporter, or the distributor.
• Quality Risks: Product quality can be affected by factors such as storage, transportation, and handling at each intermediary stage. For example, food products can deteriorate if not stored at the correct temperature during transportation or warehousing.
• Price Risks: Product prices can fluctuate due to factors like market supply and demand, exchange rates, and transportation costs. For example, a spike in fuel prices may increase shipping costs, affecting the final price of the product.

Enhanced Market Access:

• Market Expansion: Products can reach various markets around the world, increasing business opportunities. For example, a specialty tea from Vietnam may be sold in Europe, North America, and other Asian countries through a global distribution network.
• Utilizing Distribution Networks: Intermediaries often have extensive distribution networks that help products reach consumers quickly. For example, a large distributor may have a network of stores across an entire country, making it easier for products to reach consumers in all regions.

Increased Costs:

• Multiple Intermediaries: Each intermediary takes a share of the profits, leading to increased final product costs. For instance, a product that costs 100,000 VND at the factory may increase to 150,000 VND after passing through a distributor and 200,000 VND when it reaches the final consumer.
• Transportation Costs: The cost of transporting goods across multiple countries and intermediaries is significant. For bulky items or products requiring special storage conditions, these costs can account for a large portion of the product’s final price.
• Marketing Costs: Marketing expenses to promote the product to consumers also increase. Each intermediary may need to invest in advertising and promotions to attract customers, and these costs are eventually reflected in the product’s selling price.

According to USDA, transaction and management costs through intermediaries can account for about 15-20% of the final product price.

Challenges in Quality Control:

• Different Quality Standards: Each intermediary may have different quality standards, making it difficult to ensure consistent quality. For example, storage standards for a distributor in Europe may be stricter than those of a producer in Asia.
• Difficulty in Tracing Origins: Tracing the origins of a product through multiple intermediaries is challenging. This can become problematic when faulty products need to be recalled, or when consumers want detailed information about the product’s origins.

For example, Specialty Coffee from Brazil might be affected by inconsistent storage conditions during transportation and storage by intermediaries. According to research from the Specialty Coffee Association, coffee quality can degrade by about 5-10% during transportation and storage.

Improved Market Management:

• In-Depth Market Understanding: Intermediaries often have deep knowledge of local markets, helping producers make informed strategic decisions. For example, a local distributor may provide insights into consumer habits, market trends, and competitors in the region.
• Flexibility in Adjustments: Intermediaries can quickly adjust production and distribution to meet market demand. For instance, if a product is selling well in a specific market, a distributor can quickly increase orders and adjust marketing strategies to capitalize on the opportunity.

Although indirect coffee trading is prevalent in the coffee industry, its definition has not yet been formally established or consistently applied across the sector

In the coffee industry, sustainability and fair trade have become increasingly important, especially within the indirect coffee trading model.

Sustainability in Indirect Coffee Trading:
Sustainability in coffee includes protecting the environment, using resources efficiently, and supporting the development of farming communities. In indirect trading, intermediaries can play a key role in promoting sustainable practices by choosing producers that adhere to sustainability standards.

• Natural Resource Management: Distributors and exporters can encourage environmentally friendly farming practices, such as reducing chemical use, conserving water, and maintaining fertile soil.
• Improving Social Conditions: Intermediaries in the indirect trading model can help improve the living and working conditions of farmers through support programs and collaborations. They can also contribute to community projects, such as building schools, hospitals, and other infrastructure.

Fair Trade in Indirect Coffee Trading:
With many intermediaries involved, indirect coffee trading can impact aspects of fair trade.

• Fair Compensation for Farmers: Ensuring farmers receive fair compensation can be challenging in this model, as each intermediary may reduce the farmers’ share of the profits to optimize costs. Fair Trade certification was created to address this issue. Specifically, Fair Trade coffee exporters and distributors must pay fair prices and ensure that farmers receive a fair portion of the sales price.
• Transparent Pricing: Exporters and distributors must also be transparent about pricing and related costs to ensure that the price paid to farmers is fair.
• Fair Working Conditions: Fair trade not only concerns pricing but also the working conditions of farmers. All parties must ensure that farmers work in safe environments, are not discriminated against, and receive fair wages.

Through intermediaries, farmers can access vast global markets that they would otherwise be unable to reach on their own

Each coffee distribution model has its own advantages and disadvantages. Choosing between indirect and direct coffee trading depends on the goals and specific needs of the parties involved in the coffee supply chain.

Shifts in the market, consumer demand, and global factors may influence and change how indirect coffee trading operates and evolves in the future.

Increasing Transparency:

With the growing demand for transparency in supply chains, coffee companies will need to provide detailed information about the origins and production processes. Technologies like blockchain and advanced tracking systems can help improve traceability and ensure product quality. This will enable consumers to have greater insight into the origins and quality of their coffee.

Enhancing Sustainability:

Environmental and social issues are becoming increasingly important, and all parties will need to invest more in sustainability initiatives. This includes reducing the environmental impact of production and improving farmers’ working conditions.

Indirect coffee trading will likely see a rise in sustainability programs and certifications like Fair Trade and Rainforest Alliance, ensuring that coffee products meet sustainability and fairness standards.

Adopting Digital Technology:

In the age of Industry 4.0, digital technology and data analytics will be indispensable for optimizing distribution processes and improving supply chain management. Intermediaries will use data to predict demand, manage inventory, and improve efficiency.

Developing Premium Markets:

Consumers are increasingly interested in premium coffee products such as Specialty Coffee – beans with distinct characteristics and proud regional origins. This will push distributors and exporters to focus on providing high-quality and unique products rather than simply optimizing costs.

Environmental and social issues are becoming increasingly important, and stakeholders will need to invest more in sustainability initiatives

Conclusion

Despite significant challenges related to cost, quality, and transparency, indirect coffee trading plays a vital role in the global supply chain. The complexity of the distribution process and the involvement of many intermediaries create both business opportunities and issues that need to be addressed. However, with increasing demands for transparency, sustainability, and digital technology, the indirect trading model is gradually adapting to meet the needs of the modern market. In the future, a focus on sustainable standards and product quality will be key to the development and success of indirect coffee trading.

Image collected by XLIII Coffee

1. What is indirect coffee trading?

Indirect coffee trading refers to transactions in which coffee is sold from producers to consumers through intermediaries such as exporters, importers, distributors, and retailers.

2. How does indirect coffee trading affect the final product price?

Indirect coffee trading often leads to increased costs due to the involvement of multiple intermediaries, raising the final price of the product.

3. What sustainability factors are reflected in indirect coffee trading?

Sustainability factors in indirect coffee trading include natural resource management, improving the social conditions of farmers, and supporting community projects.

4. How does fair trade impact farmers in indirect coffee trading?

Fair trade in indirect coffee trading ensures that farmers receive fair prices and decent working conditions through certifications such as Fair Trade.

5. How does digital technology improve the indirect coffee trading model?

Digital technologies, such as blockchain and data analytics, improve the indirect coffee trading model by optimizing distribution processes, enhancing traceability, and managing supply chains more effectively.